New Page 1

Search This Site
 

 

 



 

 

 
 

 

 

 

 

Cable or Satellite?
Ben [Finally] Cut The Cable:
Here's Why You Will, Too!
 
You might be like me and have been hearing the barrage of ads on the radio urging you to "cut the cable" and get more bang for your buck with a satellite TV receiver system.  Maybe I'm discrediting myself with this next statement, but I put it resisted the urge because cable was a "known evil." 

A Little Background
 
Although I'd been a cable subscriber for over 16 years, watching my local cable provider change their name about as often as a bank or S&L in Texas in the 1980s, the service had always been good.  I was blessed to be in Fort Worth and be subjected to a cable monopoly that defied the usual stream of "cable guy" jokes that Letterman and Leno have made for years.  And just as I was about to "cut the cable" in October 2000 and take the satellite plunge, I got a telemarketing call from my local cable provider, Charter Cable, offering this new-and-improved digital cable service...giving me over 150 channels for the introductory price of only $33 a month...for six months, then the price would revert to prevailing price schedules.

The Cable Guy Shows Up On Time!
 
With the added pressure of competition from the fledgling satellite TV industry, cable providers around the country have had to clean up their acts and do their best to defy the long-running "waiting on the cable guy" jokes because–FINALLY–consumers had a choice and could give make their voices heard by telling the cable company to stick their boxes where the cable doesn't shine.  And predictably, the cable guy showed up and installed my new digital cable boxes, gave me an instructional video and a laminate channel guide, a quickie explanation of how all of the menus worked, and I was off to the races with a zillions channels, crystal-clear digital picture and sound, and a new viewing experience awaiting me every time I turned on the set.  So far, so good...until April, 2001.

Like Those Deceptive Credit Card Offers...My Cable Bill TRIPLES!
 
I'm a big boy and I knew that my bill was going to go up after the introductory offer that they sold to me six months ago expired.  The credit card companies pioneered "the tease" over the last couple of decades, baiting all of us to switch cards and transfer balances to take advantage of the low 2.9% interest rate.  Hell, when you're paying 12% or more [you already know that over 18-20% interest rates isn't uncommon!] you'll jump to cash in on the low introductory rate, knowing that they'll push it back up after the offer expires. 
 
But as I've preached on countless local and national TV shows for years–and this strategy still works I might add–if you call your credit card company and threaten to close your account and move your balance to another credit card, your existing credit card company will almost always do the old back-pedal and agree to extend your current cheapo interest rate for another 6-9-12 months, because they realize that if they don't, they stand a very good chance of losing you to a competitor...and in the long run, it's cheaper to appease you and keep you as a customer than have to replace you.  So they'll play ball.  Unfortunately, as I found out in April 2001, the local cable provider [at least in Fort Worth] didn't share in this philosophy.  And it's going to cost them dearly in the long run.

The Prevailing Cable Company Attitude: Take Your Business Elsewhere!!!
 
When I contacted the customer service voice at my local cable provider after my bill soared from $33 a month to $99, and asked them to re-extend the offer that hooked me in the first place, they couldn't care less.  "Sorry.  Too bad.  Can't do it!" was the reply.  "But if you refuse to cut me a deal, I'll cut the cable and sign up for satellite TV and you'll lose me forever!  And look at my account history: I always pay on time, and I've been a loyal customer since 1985!!!  Are you sure you can't "re-up" my deal to keep me?"  "I'm sorry sir.  The offer you had was for new digital cable customers.  I can't help you."
 
Perhaps Johnny Paycheck needs to update his anthem and change it to reflect the times: "Take This Cable Box And Shove It!"

Bye-Bye Cable: Which Satellite Company Should I Choose?

 
Now that Charter Communications made my decision to [finally] take the technology plunge into satellite TV, I walked the walk and talked the talk, and started doing my comparisons between Dish Network and DirecTV.  I chose Dish...and here's some of the reasons why:
 
* 1. Pricing: Do your homework...and remember that the satellite companies are extremely competitive and seemingly always have a deal-du-jour. Bottom line? They both offer [basically] the same channels, the same movie packages, the same Pay Per View movies and events.

However, when I took the plunge,
Dish seemed to have the best sign-up offer. Their commitment was less onerous than DirecTV's, but the real reason I chose Dish? One of the coolest features you'll love if you take my advice...priced better than the competition and it'll change the way you watch TV; the greatest new TV technology that you'll thank me for later: DVR–Digital Video Recorder.
 
* 2.  Take Dish over DirecTV for the DVR: The DVR is actually a big computer hard drive that'll record over 100 hours of programming that's pristine and incredibly simply to use. And with Dish, it's included with the system. And the last time I checked, DirecTV's version of the DVR, the TiVo (which was actually the first entry into this type of technology) costs extra, unlike the DVR that comes with the Dish system. According to DirecTV's website, you'll have to ante up $249 for a lifetime TiVo subscription, or pay as you go for $9.95 a month. Dish and their DVR win, hands-down.

* 3.  Channels. We've Got Channels: Whether it's cable,
Dish or DirecTV, everybody's promoting 100 channels, or 150 channels...plus whatever premium services packages, like HBO, Showtime, Starz, etc. you want to sign up for. The reality? Out of the 150 "included" channels that I get on my Dish system, dozens of the channels are junk that I could care less about and will never watch. How many versions of the Discovery Channel can you stomach? How often will you listen to the dozens of subscription music channels being offered? If you don't like certain types of music now, you'll never listen to them through your cable or satellite delivery systems. In my book, as long as I've got the assorted news channels, Nick At Nite and TV Land, I'm happy.

* 4. What About Receiving My Local Channels? Will I Have A Problem Watching The Local "Major" Affiliates? Relax! The cable industry hammered the fears [ignorance, actually] of consumers about their ability, on inability, to receive the local TV channels. Thanks to lobbying of the FCC by the folks at
Dish and DirecTV, you can buy your local affiliates [known as DMA: Designated Market Area] for $4.99 extra a month, whether you're in Texas or California or anywhere else around the nation.

Or you can tap into the pre-existing cable or antenna to get your local channels. Bottom line: It's no big deal, so don't let this be a stumbling block to keep you from getting more bang for your TV viewing buck. Even if you pay the extra $5 a month for local channels, you'll still end up getting more value from satellite delivery systems with less than brain-damage than the cable company. Period.

* 5.  Biggest Red Flag That PROVES Dish Is Better Than DirecTV or Cable?
Easy. Just go to the websites of the programming provider you're researching. Seriously...check out how difficult it is to figure out how much their services will cost you. You can jump through pages of "information gathering" questionnaires from the cable company and never figure out how much you'll pay if you decide to sign up with them. There's a reason for this. They want to not only hide how much their services will cost, they want to set you up for a representative to call and sell/try to close you.
The easiest website to navigate and get a bottom-line cost from? You guessed it: Dish.

* 6.  Don't I Get A Better Deal If I Buy All Of My Services [like Internet access, telephone, etc.] From One Company?
Not necessarily. That's the pitch you'll hear from folks like AT&T (they want to sell you everything, all inclusive/all in one for one bill a month) but frankly, I don't like putting all of my eggs in one basket. What if that basket falls? You're willing to lose your TV, Internet AND phone service all at once? Not me, thanks.

* 7.  I Live In An Apartment [or Condo] And I Have To Subscribe To Cable, Don't I? No! As plainly stated on DirecTV's website about this subject: "You don't have to own a house to get great satellite service! As a resident of a condo or apartment, you can set up your own system or your entire building could be served from just one dish. If you want to install your own system, first check with your landlord or property manager for permission to install the satellite dish on your rooftop. If you are not able to install it on a rooftop, you may be able to install it on your private balcony or patio or in your garden, as long as the satellite dish has a clear view of the southern sky. In fact, a January 1999 FCC ruling states that apartment, condominium, town home and single family home renters can install either satellite dishes or TV antennas in these areas. In fact, the FCC has ruled that apartment, condominium, town home and single family home renters can install either satellite dishes or TV antennas in these areas."

In other words: You don't have to let your landlord hold a gun to your head and force you to subscribe to cable, especially crappy cable. Don't take my word for it:
Check out this special section on the FCC's website that explains the rules better than I can. Now everyone has the legal right to have access to quality, affordable satellite TV service!

And speaking of lousy cable providers, one of the all time worst cable providers in the history of the technology has to be a company previously known as Co-Serve, also known as Cable Plus. I think the new title correctly reflects the quality of the company's service: Cable Plus Thoughtless-Lousy-and-Overpriced Service! This is a horrible company: They go in and cut deals with apartment complexes and force the tenants to subscribe to their cable service. Their offerings are limited, overpriced and customer service, non-existent. The FCC rule that allows everyone equal access to quality satellite service must have been written with this awful company in mind.

* 8. What About My Ability To Get ESPN1, ESPN2, And All Of The Sports I Can Stand? What about it? Whatever the cable companies can do, the satellite programming companies can do just as well. Relax and go do your homework. And prepare to
get more bang for your TV buck from satellite than you will from the cable company.

* 9. What About Bad Weather? What about bad weather? Sure, a torrential downpour/thunderstorm will disrupt your satellite service, but it's temporary. And if it's not, you need to be worrying about evacuating, not watching TV. How many backhoes have interrupted satellite TV service? The Answer? None. All of the brain-damage with cable interruption goes away when you put up the satellite dish. You might have a little bit of interference from a big storm, but for me, it's never been a huge factor.

* 10. What If I Have More Than One TV Set? Can I Get Satellite On Multiple Sets Around The House? Of course. I've got three sets and
Dish reception on all three. It's a no-brainer. The cable companies used to use this as an effective scare tactic to get consumers to not buy/not try satellite service, but thankfully, you're wising up.

* 11. Why Do You Hate The Cable Company So Much? Because their cavalier attitude after I was a loyal subscriber for 16 years really ticked me off. And because they're like a drug dealer: They "get you hooked" on their services, then slowly push their prices up, up, up and into the ridiculous range. And they're simply not competitive when you compare what they offer with what you can get for a lot less through satellite programming providers. And again, I'm sold on
Dish over DirecTV because I think the value Dish delivers is better. Plus the DVR technology is amazing. And I like Dish's customer service mantra, and the fact that when you call these guys at SatPro Network, you'll get the owner on the phone...not some operator.  I'm a believer.

* 12. Okay, You've Got My Attention: What Are Some Resources I Can Review To Make The Cable Vs. Satellite Decision For Myself? Easy. What ever you learn from this section, at the very least, get rid of the cable company!!! Here's some resources that will help you see the light:

Consumer Reports side-by-side comparison: If you can wade through all of the symbols, go for it.

E-Pinion.com: Don't take my word for it...go compare cable vs. satellite. Then sign-up for your new Dish.
 
* Please Note: Dish vs. DirectTV offers change all the time.  I can't keep up with all of their assorted deals of the day, so you're gonna have to do your own homework before you pull the trigger.  The technology keeps getting better, and the competition between the satellite companies, as well as between them and the cable industry means one thing...better deals for consumers.

Get your weekly Dose of Dover!

Your E-mail Address:
Zip Code   
Subscribe
Un-Subscribe
Powered by Web Wiz Guide
Recommend It!

Tell A Friend about this page Ben's Privacy Policy

 

 

 

Spacer

 

 

 

panic button Home Page Sponsor Info Contact Us Search This Site
Ben's Privacy Policy    All Content © 2008, Dover Media  All Rights Reserved